EmigrantDirect American Dream Savings Account Yields 3.0%
Unless you live in Big Apple, you probably had never heard the name Emigrant Savings Bank until two months ago. This New York local brick-and-mortar bank is now advancing to the Internet by promoting its flagship Emigrant Direct American Dream Savings Account with 3.0% APY -- the nation's highest for a no-fee savings account, at least to my knowledge. The bank is also FDIC-insured, so the first $100,000 for each account type is protected by the government.
As you know, I have no afraid of trying new financial products, so I opened a new account at EmigrantDirect lately. However, my account-opening experience with EmigrantDirect is not a smooth one.

It requires several steps to open an account at EmigrantDirect:
First, one have to go to the EmigrantDirect site, click "Open Now", and fill several forms. You will be asked for some multiple-choice credit-related questions like which bank holds your mortgage and where you lived before -- the same questions when you request your (free) credit reports online. Emigrant Direct will also ask for the information about your checking account, to which your future EmigrantDirect account will be linked to.
Second, EmigrantDirect will post two small transactions to your checking account, and ask you to verify the amount to prove you are the authentic account owner of the checking account. Upon success validation of the checking account, EmigrantDirect will send you a snail mail to your mailing address with your account number.
Once you receive your account number thru USPS, you can sign up for the online account access. For me, I had a hard time in this step getting myself signed up and had to call customer service to get it resolved. (EmigrantDirect's CSR is nice, cheerful and helpful, though.)
Sometimes, I am bothered by the fact that many online banking products requires snail mail as a double security check of your information. I can understand the small deposit check, which is a necessary one because someone can easily get your checking account information by obtaining one of your checks, but to validate your mailing address after validating your key credit information from the credit report is definitely an overkill for me. To this extent, I love Virtualbank and ING Direct, whose account-opening process is 100% online.
Anyway, 3.0% APY is a good thing: for the current size of my liquid cash, I can easily earn $100 more every year. I can complain about the account-opening hassle, but I will never complain about a higher interest rate.
(This post is part of PFBlog Product Review series. Check out more reviews here.)

Over years, I've written a lot of product reviews at PFBlog.com. It is probably time for me to provide a catalog for all reviews so here it is: (Last updated: February 7, 2005) Read
If you are a frequent Amazon.com shopper, you might want to consider Amazon's first membership program, Amazon Prime. For $79 a year, you can enjoy free two-day shipping for most of your Amazon orders for the entire year. Plus, you are entitled to $3.99 per ... Read
This time last year, I discussed IRS's Free File Alliance, a consortium of 15 companies that offers free online tax filing. If you read my notes last year, you will notice that no single company offers the free service to everybody. This year, the landscape ... Read
If you make a lot of charitable donations every year, you might consider using a software to track how much you donated for tax purposes. These software usually cost about $10 and they are sometimes sold for free after mail-in rebate if you purchase a ... Read
I agree with you completely. I was so surprised at home many steps were required and how long it took for my money to become available. There also seemed to be no guidance whatsoever on their website, which, by the way sucks, about all the steps.
EmigrantDirect is probably the worst online bank I delt with. They have a website that honestly a 13 year old created and their GUI for money transfer really puts into question the whole integrety of the bank. Coming from the West Coast, I know that Emigrant Bank is a large institution back east, but by how the website and the user interface is presented, it's amazing they got any business. Also, prepare to have a 30-40 min wait to talk to anyone "live". Plus once you do, they don't really know any more about the process than I do.
