My Personal Finance Journey

Personal finance observation, musing and decisions in a journey toward financial independence by 36 with at least $1 million.




By Topics

Overall:
| Progress (84)
| Key Analysis (113)
| Resources (119)

My Finance:
| Credit (61)
| Insurance (11)
| Car & Home (21)
| Services (11)
| Savings (27)
| Tax (28)
| Others (31)

My Readings:
| Credit (45)
| Insurance (11)
| Car & Home (43)
| Services (5)
| Savings (21)
| Tax (44)
| Investments (71)
| Economy (16)
| Others (70)

My Portfolio:
| General (64)
| Transactions (44)
| Analysis (31)

Everything Else:
| About PFBlog (49)
| My Accounting (7)
| Misc (12)


MONTHLY ARCHIVE

Jun 2008 (2)
May 2008 (2)
Apr 2008 (5)
Feb 2008 (3)
Jan 2008 (15)
Dec 2007 (32)
Nov 2007 (6)
Oct 2007 (8)
Sep 2007 (9)
Aug 2007 (24)
Jul 2007 (2)
Jun 2007 (1)
May 2007 (3)
Apr 2007 (4)
Mar 2007 (4)
Feb 2007 (13)
Jan 2007 (6)
Dec 2006 (3)
Nov 2006 (7)
Oct 2006 (7)
Sep 2006 (6)
Aug 2006 (4)
Jul 2006 (10)
Jun 2006 (1)
May 2006 (3)
Apr 2006 (2)
Mar 2006 (6)
Feb 2006 (6)
Jan 2006 (3)
Dec 2005 (1)
Nov 2005 (9)
Oct 2005 (8)
Sep 2005 (13)
Aug 2005 (25)
Jul 2005 (16)
Jun 2005 (17)
May 2005 (19)
Apr 2005 (20)
Mar 2005 (24)
Feb 2005 (23)
Jan 2005 (36)
Dec 2004 (40)
Nov 2004 (34)
Oct 2004 (17)
Sep 2004 (21)
Aug 2004 (59)
Jul 2004 (37)
Jun 2004 (31)
May 2004 (29)
Apr 2004 (52)
Mar 2004 (49)
Feb 2004 (49)
Jan 2004 (31)
Dec 2003 (48)
Nov 2003 (52)
Oct 2003 (29)
Sep 2003 (8)
Aug 2003 (5)
Jul 2003 (2)
Jun 2003 (2)
May 2003 (5)
Apr 2003 (2)
Mar 2003 (2)
Feb 2003 (3)
Jan 2003 (29)


HOT DEALS

Best Cashback Card:
Citi CashReturns(SM) MasterCard®
5% off EVERYTHING during introductory period. (review)

Best Sign-Up Bonus:
Citi Professional Card
$100 gift card after 1st purchase (review)

Best 0% APR Card:
Discover More Card
0% APR for purchase and balance transfer for 12 months (review)

Best Business Card:
Business Gold Rewards Card from American Express: Up to 40,000 bonus points in the 1st year (review)

Best Student Card:
Citi® mtvU™ Platinum Select® free music, gift cards and more (review)

Best Savings Account:
ING Direct Savings Account (4.30% APY)

Best Interest Checking:
Electric Orange from ING DIRECT. (Free Bill Pay. Earn up to 5.00% APY)

Free Stock Trading:
100% Free Stock Trading from Zecco.com

Free Credit Score:
Free Credit Report and Score from Experian



 

Am I Priced out of Roth IRA?

Contributed by mm | August 24, 2005 12:45 PM PST

When I wrote my Financial Plan 2005, one particular concern I had is whether I would be earning too much to contribute to Roth IRA:

"One important number to study from this tax analysis is the AGI. My projected AGI of $148,028 brings me very close to $150,000, which is the starting point of Roth IRA contribution limit phase-out. To bring my AGI down, I already subscribe to a big FSA contribution and max out 401(k) -- this means I need to plan my capital gains/losses more carefully to avoid triggering this phase-out schedule."

For this very reason, so far this year, I only made a $4,000 contribution to my own Roth IRA account, but didn't make the same contribution to my wife's account. Now that I have more visibility of my 2005 financials, it is time to review this topic again.

Several things have changed since I made the plan for 2005. Specifically:

First, my career at Microsoft has been successful, and I expect to improve over the budgeted job income thanks to extra bonus and salary increases.

Second, as part of the expatriation deal I'm working on, I'm looking at additional allowances for housing and transportation for at least two months of 2005 (and ongoingly in 2006 and 2007). Plus, it is very likely that all the relocation benefits will show up in my W-2 too.

Third, to work on the Hercules' task of moving, and enjoy some happy Seattle summer afternoons, my wife resigned from the job earlier this month. (Read: reduced income.)

Finally, I have to admit PFBlog has some (commercial) success. Though still insignificant compared to my job income, advertising income from various channels has exceeded my original expectation by a few grand.

So, I ran the calculation again, and it turns out my modified AGI, as defined in IRS Pub. 590, would be $158,000 before I add any relocation benefits. The conclusion: I'm pretty much priced out of Roth IRA, which only allows contribution from couples with modified AGI at less than $160,000.

It is time to place a call to Fidelity and discuss how I can pull back some contributions so I don't have to pay the 6% excise tax on over contributed amount.

(P.S. The definition of Modified AGI requires me to add back the foreign earned income. Since I have exhausted tactics like 401(k) contribution and FSA, I hardly have any other ways to bring the modified AGI back to under $160,000.)

More PFBlog Articles You Might Find Interesting ...


This Post Has Received 15 Comments. Share Your Opinions Too.


Jeff Commented on August 24, 2005

Do you qualify for a SEP IRA? You seem to be partially self-employed now.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEP_IRA


Caitlin Commented on August 24, 2005

Or even an Individual 401(k)? (allows even more to be put aside pre-tax)

Fidelity has them, initial paperwork is a bit crufty, but it's a good deal once you have one)


taupecat Commented on August 24, 2005

Don't you just hate that? The income limits for Roth IRAs, I mean. For all of Bush's preaching that Social Security needs to go to private accounts and yadda yadda, I really wish he'd actually get around to the tax reforms like he promised. Fixing little chesnuts like this, the AMT, and just the huge, Gordian mess that is the American tax code would go a long way in helping average Americans save their own money for retirement.


Joe K. Commented on August 25, 2005

Taupecat - I would hardly call someone earning more than AGI of $160,000 "an average American". I wish everyone would have such problems. While I think there is a strong argument to simplifying the tax code - I get the feeling when I talk about this, the people who want changes to the tax code are mostly the well off. You have to remember that if your family earns above $100K you are probably in the top quartile of income earners in this country (not sure of the statistic but it is probably ballpark). The greatness in this country is that while income disparity has always existed it wasn't as pronounced as many other places. I get the feeling that is changing. Sadly simplifying the tax code will not help the vast majority of Americans. What is needed in my mind is a more equal distribution of wealth in the jobs that average people have - pay more to teachers and firefighters and middle level employees of companies. While this might seem bad for the wealthy in the short run (increased or unchanged taxes) it will be best for this country in the long run and continue to develop prosperity by having more people who have "average American" jobs still have standards of living that are the best in the world.


Joshua Ross Commented on August 25, 2005

Joe. K - Tell the teachers to teach skills in higher demand. Tell the firefighters to work part time or run a business while they have all that free time sitting around at the station. Tell the average american to not be so average, and do something that makes them deserve to be paid higher than the average american. All the jobs you metioned appeal to the emotions of the american tax payer, but they do not deserve higher pay on that logic alone. Skills and productivity drive wages, and if you don't have to use either one, then don't expect your wages to be going anywhere soon either. I know baggage handlers used to be able to raise a family on their wages and even send their kids to college, but we have to look at the reality of the situation. We cannot compete on a global scale with wages for unskilled labor going for $60K. Instead, not only will the baggage handler not have a job, but everyone in the whole company will eventually be finding a new job when a foreigner buys the airline and sells it off in chunks.


MM Commented on August 25, 2005

Thank you Jeff and Catilin. Yes, I need to study these options. Will post results online.


Guest Commented on August 25, 2005

Find your place in the world. I think you'll find that even at a teachers/firefighter's salary, you are still rather wealthy compared to the rest of the world.

http://www.globalrichlist.com


Flexo Commented on August 25, 2005

The global rich list is interesting but probably irrelevant. But Joshua, people who choose to be firefighters know the salaries they're expected to earn, and those who work for a cause (whether it's saving lives or non-profit, for example) understand that there's not the same kind of money as there is in being an upper-level executive in a corporation.

You're confusing "skills and productivity" -- of which you say there should be more education -- with "desire and means to get ahead in the corporate/business world."

I'm curious as to how to figure out the salary someone "deserves" in your mind. Generation of corporate profits?

If the average American salary is $38,428, what is it about teachers that makes you think they should make less? This puts a salary of $150,000 way above average. When one is immersed in the corporate world, it's hard to understand that because there are a whole lot of people making around that much. It's difficult to see outside of one's close circle.

I'm completely fine with limiting Roth IRA and tax-favorable contributions for people with high salaries. They have the means to save for retirement without assistance from the government.


Flexo Commented on August 25, 2005

I linked to the source of the average salary figure but my HTML was stripped:

http://usgovinfo.about.com/b/a/009620.htm


MM Commented on August 25, 2005

Believe me, I didn't intend to make this post a debate about class warfare :-) I totally support the limit -- at the very least, it is a good challenge to find alternative strategies to keep more money. Keep tuned for my next series.


taupecat Commented on August 25, 2005

Joe K. - A lot of it depends where in this country you live. Granted, $150K in MOST parts of this country is indeed high income, but in higher cost of living areas (New York, San Francisco, Seattle all come to mind), $150K doesn't take you as far as you'd think. And that's another problem with the tax code, it's one size fits all which is certainly not the case in this country. Just compare median home prices in NYC, Des Moines, Honolulu, etc. And another point -- the income limit for a full Roth IRA contribution is $95K for single, $150K for married filing joint. What kind of math gets 2 X $95K = $150K ??? It just doesn't make sense to me. These income limits are arbitrary and serve no purpose considering how little $3K is to one's overall retirement plan really (it's a number only slightly adjusted from 1980's levels). No, I don't want to debate the socio-economic class structure of this country either; I just want the tax code to make sense.


Midwest Mike Commented on August 25, 2005

Even though one can't contribute to a Roth past the $160k mark..you can still contribute to a traditional IRA (only catch here is that the contribution is not deductible off your taxes; however: the sum still grows tax free like a traditional IRA. Again..the only difference here is that you can't deduct the upfront contribution...but on the backside, you get taxed when you withdraw the amount (just like you would with the typical traditional IRA).

Key here: you don't get to deduct on the front-side and you don't withdraw tax free on the backside..but it's still away to shelter more income for tax-free growth during the interim.

Midwest Mike


Poor American Commented on August 26, 2005

I'm really tired of reading all these articles about people making $120K, $150K, $200K and how they're "barely getting by" due to high cost of living, or high home prices, or something else. The simple fact is, if they are having financial troubles, they're living beyond their means. I absolutely guarantee someone making that much (even with a 2.5 kid family) could survivce financially ANYWHERE in the country. They just need to stop living like they have a net worth of $20M. Further, the Roth IRA phase out amount should really be lowered -- it's too high as it is. People making that much have enough advantages as it is -- they really don't need another tax break when their high-priced accountant has likely saved them thousands more than the average taxpayer though loopholes.


drury Commented on August 26, 2005

A taxed brokerage account can sometimes make more sense than plugging more into an IRA that is non-deductible and will be taxed as ordinary income upon withdrawal. LT cap gains would max at 15% at todays rates.


Wes Commented on August 30, 2005

drury - I totally agree with you on your point.

My wife and I have two large buckets (with many little buckets, ie. accounts). The two large buckets are PRE-TAX retirement savings and POST-TAX retirement savings.

The pre-tax accounts are for when we are actually retired and the post-tax accounts are for our early/semi-retirement years. i.e. when we hit 50 (or sooner).

I have a 401k and a SEP but am priced out of ROTH and deductible IRA's and so a post-tax retirement account was my best next option.

On my post-tax accounts I'm using some great tax efficient ETF strategies to minimize tax impacts.

-Wes



Read More ... 27 Posts In The Same Category



Recommended Offers










This page was last rebuilt at May 12, 2008 10:31 PM PST.
 

RSS FEED



PREMIUM SPONSORS

Car Loans
Business Cash Advance
Injury Claims
Car Finance
Bad Credit Loans - Free Quote
Homeowner Loans
Payday Loans
Used Cars
Loans
Commercial Mortgages and Business Loans
Car Leasing
Payday Loan
Personal Loan
Secured Loans


SITE REVIEWS

Low Cost Loans
Cheap Loans


PERSONAL FINANCE BLOGS I READ

Consumerism Commentary
Get Rich Slowly
My Money Blog
All Financial Matters
The Simple Dollar




SELECTED POSTS

Credit Cards:

Best 0% APR Intro Offers

Citi CashReturns MasterCard

Citi Payment Partner Program

American Express Blue Cash

Free Credit Report

Banking:

Emigrant Direct Savings Account

Investing:

Opening A Self-Employment 401(k) Account

Real Estate:

Most Affordable Housing Markets

Insurance:

Auto Insurance Saving Tips

Vehicle Insurance Ratings

Other Services:

ooma - free domestic calling for life



.

Featured Sites


Student Loans - Confused about student loans? Have a professional education finance advisor assist you with all of your federal and private student loan questions. Also find free college financing tools and resources at NextStudent.com.

• Protected.co.uk compare over 300 life insurance plans to find the best deal from their providers.

• Search 300 life insurance plans from 12 leading providers.

payday loans - Payday Loans No Credit Check can offer you with reasonably-priced loans for you financial requirement.We deals in Payday UK, Payday Loans Australia , payday Loans Canada.

Bad Credit Auto Loans are loans for people who have a poor credit history and cannot qualify for an auto loan. If you are able to secure a bad credit auto loan, you should consider it to be a second chance to improve your credit rating by making all auto loan payments on time.

Car Finance - The Uk's leading online car finance company. Buy any car from any UK dealership. Bad credit not a problem.

• SecuredLoansCentre.co.uk - 3 easy steps to compare over 200 secured loan plans for UK home owners in minutes

• Find a fast personal loan in the UK. Even if you have a bad credit history, arrears or CCJ's, Loansite's top lenders can help you compare loans and find a low APR secured loan, homeowner loan or tenant loan with fast approval in principle.

• Legal Helpers experienced bankruptcy lawyers can help you out of debt. Take advantage of our Free debt consultation. Our bankruptcy lawyers will help you understand your best option to eliminate your debt. Ask about our 100% guarantee.

Cheap Car Insurance - Provides Cheap Car insurance. Receive an instant quote online

Womens Car Insurance - Specialises in cheap car insurance for women

• Have a Personal Bankruptcy Lawyer assist with filing bankruptcy for a chapter 13 or chapter 7 bankruptcy case. Free bankruptcy evaluation tool.

secured loans - Any purpose low Cost secured Loans.

• The Internet's most trusted credit card resource directory.

Frigidaire Parts

Fleet Dealer - Ford Fleet trucks and vans, cargo vans, cutaway vans, LCFs, work trucks, commercial trucks, ambulances, tow trucks, police squad vehicles, and other commercial vehicles like box vans, delivery vans, box trucks and dump trucks.

Bad Credit Auto Loans - Auto loans bad credit, bad credit auto loans, guaranteed credit approval, auto financing, credit lenders, car credit, automobile lenders, bad credit auto loans seattle, auto loans bad credit seattle.

Ford Dealer - One of the World's largest Ford Dealerships. Over 3,000 cars and trucks to choose from. Mega Volume Dealer. $1,000 price guarantee. Large Special Finance Store. Ford Dealer Seattle. Mustang, Edge, Explorer, F150, f250, fleet, build your own Ford.

Auto Loans Bad Credit - Bad Credit Auto Loans, auto loans bad credit, guaranteed credit approval, car credit car loans, automobile financing, credit lenders, bad credit auto loans seattle, auto loans bad credit seattle. (Home | Apply | Inventory | Credit Help | Contact Us)

PayDay Loans

• moneyeverything.com - Find the right credit card to suit you with our guide to the right card in the UK

• airaid.co.uk - Looking for credit cards in the UK? Find the right credit card to suit you with our guide to choosing the right card in the UK

Bad Credit Loans - find out some tips about improving your credit score and choosing the best bad credit lender.

• Consolidate debt with Bad Credit Personal Loans online or Personal Loans, consolidate Bad Credit Personal Loans or apply for Credit Cards including 0% deals.

• You may also want to look at UK Bank Accounts and get a Credit Report before comparing UK Credit Cards or finding out about UK Mortgages to refinance or move house.

• We provide personal loans for debt consolidation, home improvement, bad credit loans at cheap rates in the UK.

• If you are buying a car you may want to search for UK Car Insurance to get a car insurance quote online.

• Accepted.co.uk compare over 100 secured loans to find the best deal from their lenders.

• Accepted.co.uk compare over 100 secured loans to find the best deal from their lenders.

Sending money to family and friends has never been easy. Use iKobo, secure way to send money worldwide

Payday loan tips at paydayloanreport.net helps you to defeat cash-checking and payday loan traps.

• MM Money is an interesting money blogthat covers many aspects of personal financial matters.

• This insurance weblog covers all major types of insurance, including health, life and car insurance

• Bestcardguide.com offers independent review of best credit cards

• Real Bankruptcy offers excellent tips of bankruptcy and how to avoid them

Small Business Loans

Credit Card Debt Relief

Online Credit Card Processing

Stock Investments

online casino - reviews of goldenpalace, casino-on-net, and more. onlinecasinobluebook.com review guide.

Student Loan Consolidation - the student loan solutions provides students and their families with information and resources to help students get out of default and better manage their student debt.

Bad Credit Auto Loans - washington state's bad credit auto financing leader.

Home Loan - getsmart is a leading online financial marketplace, focused on smart consumers in a hurry.

Credit Cards - the best deals on uk credit cards compared, regularly updated

IRS Tax Lien - when you need help with your tax problems, call citizens tax relief.

bankruptcy - bankruptcy lawyers from around the country providing assistance with chapter 7, chapter 13, and debt issues

Credit Repair - repair my credit now credit services offers credit repair, restoration and education through our exclusive "v" phase process ™


Want to See Your Ads Here? Claim Your Ad Space at Personal Finance Weblog by Writing to Webmaster. Starting at $49/month, see your text ads in thousands of indexed pages at PFBlog, the Best Personal Finance Blog. Full Rate Card Available Here.

Copyright 2003-2006, PFBlog.com. All Rights Reserved. (Privacy Policy)